My recent article on how Australia gives away $45 billion a year in untaxed gas and mineral wealth prompted a few responses from readers about the cost-of-living crisis and personal freedom.
One came from a mechanical engineer working in the resources sector. This reader told me he works weeks away from home to support his family. Despite earning significantly more than his father did at the same age, and diligently paying tax, he does not have the same living standards. He feels ignored by politicians who only care about the service economy, and fears that inner-city elites want to bankrupt our export industries, cost him his job, and force him to trade his reliable 1990s Hilux (which he can service himself) for an expensive new electric car.
He and other readers posed some specific, pointed questions: Won’t higher resource taxes kill future investment? Isn’t the fuel tax credit just an off-road tax refund fairly paid to people who don’t drive on the roads? Don’t we need petroleum for steel, plastics, and heavy machinery? And how can we rely on fossil fuel taxes to fund public services if we want to phase out fossil fuels? Won’t big government just monitor our personal choices? Isn’t the cost-of-living crisis just being caused by too much government spending on unaffordable welfare?
These are the exact questions and discussion we need to have out in the open. Here are my answers.
First, nobody should touch your 90s Hilux. Owning your car outright and being able to fix it yourself is independence. The people who are actually threatening your right to repair your own ute are the giant multinational corporations locking modern cars, tractors, and trucks cars behind proprietary software and subscription paywalls. The major car companies also oppose your right to repair your own car! These are the same corporate interests who want you to remain utterly dependent on oil for your mobility — the same oil that these companies massively profit from to the tune of over $95 billion for just nine companies in six months. This is hardly freedom of choice — it’s your freedom being destroyed by corporate control.
Why does a skilled engineer earning significantly more than his dad feel poorer today? Because for forty years, our economy has been designed to funnel wealth upward to foreign-owned monopolies and the Big Four banks. While you pay your taxes in full every fortnight, multinational gas conglomerates ship two thirds of Australia’s gas offshore paying zero royalties and almost no tax (and remember there is a real, material difference between a royalty and a tax — royalties are not a tax).
When I refer to collecting $45 billion a year in resource rents for the public purse (a figure from the Prosper research here), this means taxing unearned windfall mega-profits during global price spikes. Mining and gas companies already make hugely profitable returns on their capital investment, and they still pay their engineers. As we saw in Queensland in 2022, when they raised coal royalties to 40 percent, the mines kept running and the public purse gained billions. While future greenfield gas projects require massive capital, countries like Norway capture 40 percent of petroleum value by taking direct public ownership stakes. By sharing both the investment risk and the reward, the Norwegian people benefit from massive commodity price spikes, rather than letting US investment funds like Vanguard and BlackRock pocket the lot.
These multinational gas and mining conglomerates aren’t actually “creating” wealth when they dig up the finite natural resources owned by Australians. In reality they are liquidating a shared public asset for their private gain — and let’s be clear, the public gets almost no gain. When foreign-owned monopolies siphon billions in unearned profits out of the country almost entirely tax-free, they are actively draining and reducing Australia’s productive capacity rather than expanding it. True wealth creation doesn’t come from letting corporate elites and financial markets dig up the countryside to pay short-term dividends to shareholders on Wall Street. If we genuinely want to preserve and expand our national productive capacity for the long term, we have to keep as much of those massive resources and let Australians democratically decide how use it.
Will mining and gas companies just stop their investment if we increase royalties or taxes? The reality is that these mining companies cannot move their Australian mines or gas fields to Peru or Brazil — the ore and the gas are here. However, it is also true that the global resources companies and financial investment firms have enormous power over the Australian government. This is the reason that we currently tax these resources so little right now and it is exactly why the public needs equity stakes in these massive projects, as well as decent royalties and a fair tax.
On the fuel tax credit: refunding road excise to a small family farmer is justifiable, economically and morally. It makes no sense and is morally indefensible to hand $3.4 billion a year in fuel rebates to 18 multinational mining giants who make tens of billions in profit, or to massive corporatised agribusinesses. On average, a family farmer claims about $13,000 per year in fuel tax credits, compared to the average coal mining company which claims $26 million. BHP (profits in 2024 US$7.89 billion) received $622 million in fuel tax credits in 2024 and foreign giants like Chevron pay zero tax. Even when mining companies build modest private rail lines, they rely on public ports, energy grids, legal systems, and skilled workers trained at public schools and TAFEs. If we want the system to be fairer and simpler, we should cap fuel rebates to be only available to small and medium local business and farms. The big business lobby demands endless, stringent means-testing for welfare for people but never for corporations.
What about our reliance on oil, coal, and gas for steel, fertilisers, plastics, and heavy machinery? It is true that modern society is absolutely reliant on petrochemicals — which is something that was designed and enforced by US oil companies and Wall Street investment firms. And it is absolutely obvious to everyone that burning gas and oil for electricity is completely different from using hydrocarbons as industrial feedstocks, fertilisers or medicines. Phasing out fossil fuels in power generation and freight leaves plenty of carefully managed oil and gas for essential medicines, food-production, irreplaceable lubricants, and metallurgical processes while we research non-toxic, renewable alternatives. However, the reality is that the vast majority of oil, around 86 percent, is burned for fuel, not for other purposes.
Furthermore, true Australian sovereignty and national self-reliance means not being hostage to foreign fuel conglomerates and global commodity spot pricing set in London. Australia has already drained 90 percent of its conventional crude oil and shut down all but two domestic refineries. We import 90 percent of our diesel — Australia is actually the world’s largest seaborne importer yet we also shut down our domestic maritime shipping sector to benefit foreign shipping conglomerates. Transitioning our domestic grid and heavy freight to publicly owned, domestically produced renewable energy, which supports and is supported by local manufacturing and strategic fuel reserves, would protect our supply chains and economy from international shocks and overseas wars. While we’re at it, let’s also build a domestic battery, wind turbine and component manufacturing industry here — so we’re not just trading oil import dependency for battery import dependency.
A slightly more independent Australia is what we had before trade liberalisation of the 1980s and 1990s. We could return to public ownership of monopoly electricity grids — like some states still have. While public ownership isn’t necessarily cheaper (although privatisation definitely is a lot more expensive), public grids don’t pay a 10-15 percent dividend to foreign shareholders. We could demand equity stakes in bailed-out smelters like Glencore’s Mount Isa facility or Qantas — which is exactly what happened in the UK, Germany, Ireland, even Kuwait, when national governments bailed out struggling strategic companies. In Australia, when Qantas was bailed out to the tune of $2.7 billion, it was effectively without conditions — the company then turned around and illegally sacked 1,800 staff in 2020, and offshored 850 more this year.
And yes, fossil fuel revenues aren’t endless. That is the whole point. Instead of pretending that gas will never run out and letting foreign corporations ship it all off to Wall Street, we should make sure that Australians get as much of the benefit right now. Whether that is to build a sovereign wealth fund or as a form of basic income or national dividend payment, the choice should be made democratically by Australians, not by gas company executives or global finance elites.
What about the claim from the financial press that the cost-of-living crisis is caused by too much government spending? This is a classic bait-and-switch. Government spending in Australia is the fifth lowest as a share of GDP in the developed world, and far below the average. A sick kid getting medical treatment or a disabled Australian getting a wheelchair did not cause global oil prices to spike by 60 percent. An overworked public school teacher getting a pay-rise did not force Westpac to post a $6.8 billion profit by increasing your mortgage rate or laundering money for child exploitation rings. There absolutely is genuine waste, but the reality is that most of the real rorting of public funding is from privatisation and corporate middle-men in the Big Four consulting firms like PwC and KPMG who clip the ticket. Or its waste in massive military spending, where the Defence “overspent” by $29 billion, most of which was likely pocketed by corporations like BAE and Lockheed. Blaming the cost-of-living crisis on government spending while foreign oil gas giants and banks profiteer is a fantastic example of how billionaires get working people to fight each other.
And what about the fear that a bigger government will monitor our personal choices and take away our freedoms? Look at who is actually surveilling and controlling you right now. It is private tech monopolies tracking everything you do. It is your employer using spy-tech to intrusively monitor you, even when you’re at home. It is Coles, who used Palantir spy-tech, or Bunnings, who face-scans you when you enter their store. It is insurance cartels pricing you out of a home. It is toll-road monopolies like Transurban charging you ever-increasing fees just to drive to work on roads that the public built. It is banks deciding what you can spend your money on. Publicly owning our power grid and taxing foreign gas conglomerates means reducing corporate control of your life, so you actually have the financial, real freedom to live.
Finally, domestic monopolies in banking, energy, groceries, and insurance have undeniably used the inflation crisis and global supply shocks to increase their profits. This “profit-led inflation” comes at your family’s expense.
Workers literally create all the wealth in this country — none of the gas or iron ore goes anywhere and not a single dollar of profit is made without workers. You shouldn’t take a pay cut — in fact, almost every worker in Australia is definitely being underpaid. The urgent economic transition, to a renewable economy and to a democratic economy should be democratically led by workers — something I spent years and years campaigning for through my union work on a just transition. Re-industrialising Australia with products like green steel, public grid infrastructure, refining our minerals in Australia, will require more engineers and other skilled, secure and well-paid jobs than we currently have. We can, and must, build a sovereign, re-industrialised Australia where the wealth we pull from the ground is used to build our common future.
